THE TENNESSEAN – SORING DOUBLES AT 2014 TENNESSEE WALKING HORSE NATIONAL CELEBRATION – AMERICA NEEDS USDA TO PROVIDE 2013 AND 2012 “USDA HORSE PROTECTION ACTIVITY REPORTS”

WOW03

COMMENT – CLANT M. SEAY, AAWHA – THE TENNESSEAN – SEP. 11, 2014

The USDA needs to immediately provide a “USDA HORSE PROTECTION ACTIVITY REPORT” for 2012 and 2013 in the same format as that provided for 2014. Following the 2012 and 2013 Celebrations, the USDA allowed the sore Big Lick interests to claim a 94% compliance rate. This was wrong. Instead of providing the “REPORT” which provides a CLEAR picture which shows approximately 2 of every 10 horses were SORE, it allowed the sore Big Lick to claim something it never had – 94% compliance. Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack now needs to instruct USDA APHIS Administrators Kevin Shea and Chester Gipson, DVM to IMMEDIATELY provide the REPORTS for 2012 and 2013. The American public NEEDS TO KNOW.
Clant M. Seay, Spokesperson, All American Walking Horse Alliance.

219 violations were issued at this year’s Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration
WWW.TENNESSEAN.COM

Walking horse Celebration violations double last year’s

 174  34  5LINKEDIN  12COMMENTMORE

Federal and local inspectors issued nearly twice as many soring violations at the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration as in the 2013 show, according to a U.S. Department of Agriculture report released this week.

A group of largely USDA monitors found 219 violations of the Horse Protection Act during the 11-day competition in Shelbyville. Those figures come after years when fewer violations “” including last year’s low of 110 “” were identified at the championship event.

The jump in violations comes as the Tennessee Walking Horse industry continues to writhe over accusations of widespread soring, which happens when a horse’s legs are hurt intentionally to exaggerate the high gait for which the breed is known. While industry reformers call for a federal law they say would eliminate the major causes of abuse, others say more objective testing would weed out the industry’s worst trainers and owners.

The report said those apparent signs of soring disqualified 166 competitors during the event “” 15.4 percent of all of the horses inspected.

The vast majority of the violations and disqualifications developed from horses that had signs of a banned substance on them or through the industry’s scar rule, which prohibits horses with past signs of soring from being shown.

The figures proved that federal officials were willing to enforce Horse Protection Act regulations at a higher rate than others designated to inspect, said Keith Dane, vice president for equine protection for the Humane Society of the United States.

More than 50 percent of the 389 horses inspected at the Celebration by USDA officials showed signs of soring, the federal report said.

“All these years the industry has said they’ve solved the problem, yet soring is still rampant,” Dane said.

Celebration CEO Mike Inman questioned the difference shown from this year’s figures, saying that federal officials enforced the scar rule differently than in years past. He said that using fewer subjective ways to monitor a horse would bring more consistent inspection results.

“We’ve had the same horses and the same inspectors for years,” Inman said. “The only thing that’s changed is the interpretation.”

Officials with the USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service said no inspection procedures were altered during the Celebration, department spokeswoman Tanya Espinosa said.

Instead, she said, inspectors were using more advanced technology to identify sored horses and penalize their trainers. This year, thermal imaging was used to better recognize abnormal temperatures that can show signs of abuse.

“Soring practices are always evolving and require APHIS to incorporate state of the art technology to capture soring techniques that may not be visible to the naked eye,” Espinosa said in an email.

She did not respond to additional questions about whether the technology used was tied to this year’s rise in violations.

Call for legislation

Because of the technology present, Dane slammed the calls for more objective testing by Celebration officials.

“They ask for science, and when they don’t like the results, they object,” Dane said. He cited the number of violations in repeating his call for Congress to approve the Prevent All Soring Tactics Act, which would ban the chains and special pads tied to the most competitive levels of the industry.

Inman supported alternative legislation that he said would strengthen current laws and provide more objective ways to evaluate a horse and eliminate the field’s worst abusers.

“The PAST Act seeks to eliminate soring by eliminating the breed,” Inman said.

Only one of the USDA violations was issued against a flatshod horse, a performance category that doesn’t use padded shoes or other devices. Because multiple violations could be issued to a horse, the number of violations could differ from the number of disqualifications, the report said.

Reach Brian Wilson at 615-726-5970 and on Twitter @brianwilson17.

WOW03