LEWISBURG, TN – Former two term TWHBEA President Marty Irby asked TWHBEA for a pro rata refund of his $1,000.00 Lifetime Membership in an October 28, 2014, letter addressed to TWHBEA Executive Director Tracy Boyd.
Irby charged TWHBEA with not supporting the welfare of Tennessee Walking Horse breed.
Irby was a life-long sore Big Licker, before he became a born-again Flatter in summer 2013.
While advocating the Big Lick way of life, Marty Irby ironically engineered the successful Big Lick resistance to a Sound takeover of TWHBEA in December 2012. He backed Tracy Boyd over the late Stephen Brown for TWHBEA President, and Boyd won.
Then in early 2013, Irby saw the light and became a Flatter. He diligently worked to persuade the 2012-2013 TWHBEA Executive Committee to endorse passage the PAST ACT. In May 2013, seven members of the TWHBEA Executive Committee endorsed the PAST ACT.
The “YES” votes included;
Joyce Moyer – 8
Carolina Hoffman – 14
Rick Wies – 11
Denise Bader Keyser – 5
Dr. Linda Montgomery – Not Pictured
Pat Stout – 7
Tracy Boyd – 1
In September 2013, TWHBEA VP Pat Stout polled the TWHBEA membership on the “PAST ACT” and 63% voted “YES” and 37% voted “NO”.
Then the Executive Committee coalition for the PAST ACT fell apart in Fall 2013 with:
Dr. Linda Montgomery – Alabama
Denise Bader Keyser – Germany
switching over and voting with the Sore Big Lickers on several crucial issues.
Montgomery and Bader-Keyser cast solid Big Lick votes opposing Electronic Voting which would have allowed Directors to vote by use of technology.
Dr. Montgomery was particularly damaging to the Sound Horse cause when she suddenly opted out of serving on the TWHBEA Nominating Committee because she wanted to run for an Executive Committee slot. This caused a realignment leading to a Big Lick takeover. Then Montgomery was elected to the 2013-2014 Executive Committee only to see the Big Lickers turn on her and ignore and isolate her. Montgomery ended up resigning from the Executive Committee, but only after first heavily damaging the interests of the Sound Horse.
DR. LINDA MONTGOMERY
DENISE BADER KEYSER – FLATTER IN DEUTSCHLAND AND BIG LICKER IN U.S.
The sore Big Lick Steve Smith/Walt Chism crowd took over in December 2013, and Tom “I’M A PROUD HPA VIOLATOR” Kakassy engineered draconian By-Law changes. Kakassy presented them in May 2014 to the Flatters who were represented at the meeting by Keith Dane, Maryland, and Dr. Pam Reband, Arizona.
The By-Laws Ballots were mailed to the TWHBEA members on September 15, 2014. ‘
The sore Big Lick Power Grab was met with flaccid and inept opposition by the Flatter Directors led by Keith Dane Maryland TWHBEA Director/HSUS official. Dane has attended and spoken on behalf of the Flatter group at TWHBEA meetings for the past two years.
FLATTER LEADER KEITH DANE, MARYLAND DIRECTOR
The Flatter Directors also bumbled by choosing to have no one present to observe the By-Laws vote count. As a direct result, the Licker hired accounting firm, Winnett & Associates of Shelbyville, Tennessee, questionably disclosed the By-Law election results to the Big Lickers who then leaked them to The Walking Horse Report on Friday, October 17, 2014.
The official By-Law election results were not released until October 22, 2014, a week after the ballots were received. The By-Law results conclusively show prove that the Flatters failed in informing and motivating TWHBEA members to vote Against the draconian By-Law changes.
The Licker’s By-Law amendment passed by 73% to 27% with a 27% turnout.
A year earlier with the effective Pat Stout TWHBEA Poll on the PAST ACT, there was a 26% turnout in which the Flatters prevailed 63% to 37%.
The By-Law election results apparently precipitated Marty Irby’s October 28, 2014 letter to TWHBEA requesting a refund.
FORMER TWHBEA PRESIDENT MARTY IRBY LETTER REQUESTING PRO-RATA REFUND OF $1,000.00 LIFETIME TWHBEA MEMBERSHIP
“From: Marty Irby
Date: October 28, 2014 12:57:45 AM CDT
To: Tracy Boyd <firstname.lastname@example.org
Cc: “email@example.com” <firstname.lastname@example.org>, Steve Smith <email@example.com>, “firstname.lastname@example.org” <email@example.com>, “firstname.lastname@example.org” <email@example.com>, Rob Cornelius <firstname.lastname@example.org>
I am writing to request a refund of my lifetime membership at TWHBEA. I purchased the membership in either November or December of 2010 for $1,000.00 and have utilized it for four years. If I had just paid the regular membership ($60.00 x 4 years = $240.00), I would have paid such, and therefore would expect the prorated refund to be $760.00.
I request this refund because in my opinion it has become very clear that TWHBEA’s leadership does not support the sound horse, and does not support the welfare of the breed. TWHBEA’s leadership does not appear to have any desire to promote and protect the horse and follow its mission.
With the passage of the recent bylaw changes I believe TWHBEA will become nothing more than a “big lick” regional country club, which may perhaps fulfill the leadership’s desire. A sad day, but alas it is what it is, and something I no longer want to be a part of.
TWHBEA seems to have nothing to offer to its members. The removal of the free registration/transfer, and the anemic latest 42 page Voice solidify this reality. Furthermore, I must mention that TWHBEA has not fulfilled the obligation of calling a meeting of the Past Presidents in 2014 as the 2012 motion and establishment of the Past Presidents Committee provide for.
Please remit payment of the refund to my address on record with TWHBEA. My funds will be better utilized with sound horse organizations that truly care about the future of the Walking Horse.
Past President 2011-2012
Past Vice President of Marketing 2007 & 2010″
Note: Irby presently serves as Director of Communications for Congressman Ed Whitfield (R-KY).
FORMER LICKER, THEN FLATTER, NOW LICKER TRACY BOYD STATEMENT
“May 27, 2013
A Statement from TWHBEA President Tracy Boyd
“This past weekend, I made perhaps the toughest decision of my life. A decision that carries potential ramifications for many of my friends. It carries potential ramifications for immediate family members as well. I, along with six other members of the Executive Committee, voted to support H.R. 1518, better known as the Whitfield Amendment. That was on Saturday morning. Before lunch, our vote was not ratified by the TWHBEA Board of Directors. Presently, TWHBEA has taken no official stance on the proposed legislation.
Let me be clear”¦ I love all facets of the Tennessee Walking Horse breed. I support the performance division. How then, you say, can I support this legislation? As president of TWHBEA, I represent the oldest and largest membership driven organization in the Tennessee Walking Horse industry. TWHBEA, being an international organization, is also the most widely recognized “brand” representing the Tennessee Walking Horse.
I have always said, “The future of the padded show horse is in the hands of two groups”¦ the trainers who train it and the owners who own it.” Unlike the American Quarter Horse Association (AQHA), for example, who controls all aspects of the Quarter Horse industry, our industry is not set up that way”¦ primarily due to the regulatory issues involving enforcement of the Horse Protection Act (HPA).
TWHBEA has no say over the padded show horse. TWHBEA has no control over the padded show horse. TWHBEA has no authority over the padded show horse. TWHBEA, does however, bear the brunt of the criticism aimed at the padded show horse. Our membership numbers are directly affected by the controversy. The group with the least input takes the hardest hit. Why? Because as the breed registry and the largest membership driven organization, we are the face of the breed and are perceived as its ultimate authority in the world equine community.
For many years, the padded show horse drove the market and TWHBEA benefited. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, when our industry was breeding 25,000 mares and registering 14,000 foals, it was largely due to the padded market. Breeders were breeding for that $15,000/$20,000 yearling. Horses were selling. New people were coming into the breed. In 1997, TWHBEA hit the 20,000-member mark and in the early 2000s operated under a 5 million dollar budget. We had some 25 or 30 employees. We were the second fastest growing breed in America and the fourth largest breed registry overall.
Today, we have fewer than 10 employees. We’ve gone to a four-day work week and cut our staff’s salaries by 20 percent. We are down to 8,300 members. Breeding production levels are at 1950s numbers. It is clear to me that what our industry is doing is no longer working in today’s world. Times have changed. The world, through technology, gets smaller and smaller every day. We can’t hide any longer. It is clear to me that our past has finally caught up with us and the image currently conveyed by our performance horse is no longer accepted in 2013.
TWHBEA has lost members in droves, and the brutal emails I have received tell me why. It is our reputation. It is soring. It is our image. My responsibility lies with TWHBEA and its 8,300 remaining members who represent all 50 states and many foreign countries.
Sadly, we have no more friends outside our industry. The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) no longer supports us. The American Association of Equine Practitioners (AAEP) no longer supports us. The United States Equestrian Federation (USEF) will not recognize our padded show horse. The American Horse Council, whom we’ve cultivated a close working relationship with for many years, has turned away from us, declining our annual sponsorship this year. The World Equestrian Games refused our sponsorship and returned it to us. The Kentucky After Christmas Sale had no performance horses this year. Last fall, the University of Tennessee featured a flat-shod horse rather than a padded show horse to perform at its annual homecoming football game. All of this breaks my heart.
I believe our modern-day padded show horses are cleaner than they’ve ever been. The problem is that nobody outside our industry believes it. And when you’ve lost the public you have lost it all”¦ and we have clearly lost the public.
For two years our industry has known that Congress would attempt to take our pads and chains unless we provided an acceptable alternative. How did we know that? Chester Gipson, Deputy Administrator for Animal Care at USDA-APHIS, told us so. He told TWHBEA, he told the Trainers’ Association, he told the Celebration and WHOA. Since that announcement the padded horse leadership’s response has been to paint the chains and implement an ambiguous swabbing program. Now the padded leadership is threatening to suspend the licenses of trainers who show under compliant HIOs. Anything beyond that”¦ “Hell No” was the answer. “No compromises!”
I understand that the Performance Show Horse Association (PSHA) may be working on proposed legislation to the Whitfield Amendment. I first heard this in January and have heard it again recently. I hope so. My understanding is that versions of the Whitfield Amendment will continue to be introduced in Congress year after year until something gets passed. It is not going away. So I applaud PSHA if they are working on an alternative. I hope they come up with something soon.
I want the performance division to survive. I believe in the need for the division. I only know that it can’t and won’t survive as it is currently presented. This to me is obvious. The padded show horse’s survival lies at the feet of the trainers who train it and the owners who own it. If I lose some friendships over my vote then so be it. But I hope and pray that the trainers who train padded horses and the owners who own padded horses will find a way to put a horse in the ring that the public can support. Until then, we will remain alienated from the mainstream equine world. It’s as simple as that.
In order for this industry to grow and attract new people, strong, bold, drastic action is needed. A different direction will be required. I just hope our industry will choose the direction rather than have it chosen for us. We all know that the pads and chains alone do not harm the horse, that is no longer the point.
For most of us, our show industry is more about people and families than it is about winning blue ribbons. It’s about the people, the fellowship, the family fun, the friendly competition. Let’s not lose sight of that.
No matter what happens with the Whitfield Amendment, proposed legislation or future versions”¦ the pads and chains do not define this breed.
The Tennessee Walking Horse is the greatest breed in the world. We all agree on that. Just imagine the possibilities that exist for us if we could rid ourselves of this black cloud, this stigma once and for all. Forty-three years is long enough.
I’m sorry to those I’ve offended and hope that one day you will forgive me.”
Nephew Eugene says it appears that the Lickers have forgiven Tracy Boyd.